How the estimator works
The disputed amount is your estimate minus the carrier’s. The slider assumes an award somewhere inside that gap; appraisal panels often land between the two numbers, but not always, and an award can also confirm the carrier’s figure. The tool then subtracts the appraiser fee you choose and, if you tick the box, half of an umpire’s fee, because in most policies each side pays its own appraiser and splits the umpire.
Reading the break-even point
Break-even tells you how far into the gap an award must land before the increase covers your costs. If break-even is above 70 or 80 percent, a line-by-line estimate second opinion and a supplement request may be the smarter first step.
What it leaves out
The estimator doesn’t model coverage disputes, depreciation timing or interest. For the holdback side of the payment, use the RCV and ACV holdback calculator.
Questions about this tool
Does an appraisal award always land between the two estimates?
No. Panels decide the amount of loss on the evidence, and an award can match either estimate or fall outside both if items were missed. The slider is a planning assumption, not a prediction.
Who pays the umpire in Michigan?
Most Michigan policies follow the statutory pattern where each side pays its own appraiser and the umpire’s cost is shared equally. Check the appraisal condition in your policy.
Is a percentage fee common?
Fee arrangements vary. Some appraisers charge flat or hourly fees, others a percentage of the increase. Whatever the structure, get it in writing before work starts.
