The umpire’s role in Michigan appraisal
Under the appraisal framework in Michigan’s Insurance Code (MCL 500.2833), each side chooses its own appraiser, and the two appraisers then select an umpire. In general terms, they have 15 days to agree on one; if they can’t, a court of record in the state can be asked to select an umpire. The umpire doesn’t act for either side. When the appraisers can’t agree on items, they submit their differences to the umpire, and a written award signed by any two of the three determines the amount of loss.
Neutral by design
When we serve as an umpire, we are not anyone’s advocate. We won’t serve as umpire in a dispute where we’ve acted as appraiser or estimate reviewer for either party, and we disclose any prior relationship with the parties, appraisers or insurer before accepting an appointment. Neutrality is the whole point; without it, the process loses its value.
How we get involved
Agreed appointment
Most often, the two appraisers agree on an umpire directly. Appraisers may contact us with the claim basics so we can check for conflicts, confirm availability and outline fee terms before both sides sign off.
Court appointment
When appraisers can’t agree, either party may ask a Michigan court of record to select an umpire. Courts sometimes consider candidates suggested by the parties. We can provide a statement of qualifications and conflict disclosure for that purpose. The decision belongs to the court.
What the process looks like
- Intake and disclosures. We confirm the parties, review for conflicts, and agree on fee terms and how they’re shared, as the policy provides.
- Submissions. Each appraiser provides an estimate, photos and supporting documents, usually with a list of items already agreed.
- Site inspection. Where useful, we inspect the property, often with both appraisers present.
- Meeting. We hear each appraiser’s position on disputed items, ask questions and request more support where needed.
- Award. We work toward a written award signed by two of the three, typically itemized so the parties can see how the amount was reached.
Keeping awards clear
A well-drafted award reduces later disputes. It typically identifies the property and date of loss, separates replacement cost and actual cash value where the policy calls for it, and notes items that were left for coverage decisions. An umpire shouldn’t decide coverage, so clear itemization helps the parties apply the award to their policy.
Learn more about each step in the Michigan appraisal process, see definitions in the glossary, or browse common appraisal questions. We serve as umpires on residential and commercial losses across both peninsulas. We are not a law firm and give no legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
How is an umpire chosen in a Michigan appraisal?
The two appraisers generally have 15 days to agree on an umpire. If they can’t, a court of record in Michigan can be asked to select one.
Who pays the umpire?
Many policies split the umpire’s fee equally between the insured and the insurer. Check your policy’s appraisal clause for its specific terms.
Can an umpire decide whether something is covered?
No. The umpire helps set the amount of loss only. Coverage questions remain for the parties, their attorneys or a court.
