A second look before you decide anything
Not every claim disagreement needs to go to appraisal. Sometimes you just need to know whether the insurer’s estimate is reasonable. Our estimate review service gives you an independent, line-by-line read of the insurer’s estimate, so you can decide your next step with real information instead of a hunch.
What we look at
Most insurer estimates in Michigan are written in estimating software with a standardized price list. That consistency is useful, but it also means errors and omissions follow predictable patterns. We check:
- Measurements. Roof squares, wall heights, room dimensions and waste factors.
- Missing line items. Starter strip, drip edge, ice-and-water shield, permits, dumpsters, content manipulation and detach-and-reset work.
- Pricing. Whether unit costs reflect current Michigan labor and material rates for your area.
- Overhead and profit. Whether general contractor overhead and profit should apply when several trades are involved.
- Depreciation. Whether depreciation was applied to items or labor in a way your policy permits.
- Scope. Whether repair methods match accepted practice and local code.
What you get
You receive a written summary of where we agree with the estimate, where we don’t, and roughly how large the difference appears to be. If the gap is small, that’s useful to know too: it may save you the cost and time of appraisal. If it’s large, you’ll have a clear list of disputed items to bring back to the adjuster or to use if you later invoke appraisal.
When a second opinion makes sense
- The insurer’s estimate seems low but you can’t point to why.
- Your contractor’s bid is far higher than the insurer’s number.
- You received a revised estimate and aren’t sure what changed.
- You’re weighing whether appraisal is worth the cost.
- A reinspection was offered and you want to know what to raise.
Do some homework first
Our guide to reading your Xactimate estimate explains the codes and columns you’ll see. The claim gap and fee estimator helps you size the difference, and the claim deadline planner helps you keep an eye on timing, since Michigan’s suit-limitation rule generally runs from the date of loss. For deadline questions, a Michigan attorney is the right resource.
A review is also useful after a reinspection or a supplement, when a revised estimate arrives with new line items and changed totals that are hard to compare with the original. We can line up the versions side by side and show what moved.
We review estimates for homes and businesses statewide, from Troy and Sterling Heights to Traverse City and the Upper Peninsula. When you’re ready, request a claim review and send us the estimate and policy.
Frequently asked questions
What do I need to send for an estimate review?
The insurer’s full estimate, your declarations page and policy if available, photos of the damage and any contractor bids. More documents make for a more useful review.
Will the insurer know I had the estimate reviewed?
Only if you share it. The review is for your information, and you decide whether and how to use it.
Does an estimate review commit me to appraisal?
No. Many people use the review simply to decide whether appraisal is worth pursuing or whether the estimate is reasonable as written.
