MichiganInsurance Appraiser

Guide · 8 min read · August 26, 2026

Appraiser, Public Adjuster or Attorney: Who Fits Your Claim?

Three different professionals help Michigan policyholders with disputed claims. Here’s how their roles, fees and timing differ.

Three roles, three different jobs

When a Michigan property claim goes sideways, homeowners hear about three kinds of help: appraisers, public adjusters and attorneys. They’re often lumped together, but they do very different things, get paid in different ways and fit different stages of a claim. Picking the right one first can save time and money. This guide explains the differences in general terms; it isn’t legal advice.

The insurance appraiser

An appraiser works inside the appraisal clause of your policy. Michigan’s Insurance Code, at MCL 500.2833, requires property policies to contain an appraisal provision, and once either side demands appraisal, each names a competent, independent appraiser. Your appraiser values the loss, inspects the property, prepares a detailed estimate, negotiates line items with the insurer’s appraiser and presents disputed items to the umpire.

An appraiser’s focus is narrow: the amount of loss. Appraisers don’t argue coverage, don’t give legal advice and don’t negotiate the claim as a whole outside appraisal. Fees are typically flat, hourly or a percentage of the award, set in writing before work starts.

Best fit: the insurer accepts that the loss is covered, but its estimate is well below what repairs will actually cost.

The public adjuster

A public adjuster is a licensed professional the policyholder hires to prepare, present and negotiate a claim with the insurer. They document damage, build the estimate, handle correspondence and push for payment. Michigan licenses public adjusters through DIFS, and their contracts are typically a percentage of the claim recovery.

Public adjusters are often brought in early, sometimes right after the loss, to manage the whole claim. Some public adjusters also serve as appraisers on other files, but on any one claim it’s wise to keep roles clear. We don’t act as public adjusters.

Best fit: a large or complicated loss where you want someone managing the entire claim from the start, such as a major fire or a commercial building after a tornado.

The attorney

A Michigan attorney is the only one of the three who can give legal advice, interpret your policy as a legal matter, file suit and argue coverage in court. If your claim has been denied, if the insurer has sent a reservation of rights letter, if you’ve been asked to sit for an examination under oath, or if the suit deadline is approaching, an attorney is the right call.

Attorneys may work on contingency, hourly or a mix. Questions about penalty interest under MCL 500.2006 or unfair claim practices under the Uniform Trade Practices Act are legal questions, and Michigan courts generally haven’t recognized a separate first-party bad-faith tort, so the legal path can be more nuanced than people expect.

Best fit: coverage denials, legal deadlines, allegations of misrepresentation or any dispute that may end up in court.

One question to sort it outAsk yourself: is the insurer saying “we don’t owe this” or “we owe less than you think”? The first usually points to an attorney. The second often points to appraisal.

Side by side

  • Scope: appraiser, the amount of loss only; public adjuster, the whole claim; attorney, legal rights and coverage.
  • When: appraiser, after a valuation stalemate; public adjuster, often early; attorney, when coverage or deadlines are at stake.
  • Pay: appraiser, flat, hourly or percentage; public adjuster, usually a percentage; attorney, contingency or hourly.
  • Legal advice: only the attorney.

Can you use more than one?

Yes, and many claims do. A homeowner might work with an attorney on a partial denial while an appraiser handles the valuation of the covered part. A public adjuster might manage a claim and then recommend appraisal when negotiation stalls. What matters is that each person has a defined role and that the appraiser stays independent. Our estimate second opinion service can help when you’re not sure yet which path fits.

An illustrative example

In an illustrative example, a Sterling Heights homeowner has hail damage. The insurer accepts the claim but pays for spot repairs on 6 squares of a 28-square roof, arguing the rest is undamaged. The dispute is about scope and amount: how much of the roof is damaged and what full replacement costs. That is an appraisal question. Now imagine the insurer instead says the damage is old wear and tear and denies the claim. That shifts toward coverage, and an attorney becomes the first call. Our hail and roof damage appraisal page explains the appraisal side in more detail.

Questions to ask before you hire anyone

  1. What exactly will you do, and what won’t you do?
  2. How are you paid, and is that in writing?
  3. Do you have any relationship with my insurer?
  4. Have you handled this type of loss in Michigan, from metro Detroit basements to U.P. snow loads?
  5. Will you tell me if your service isn’t the right fit?

Where we fit

We are independent appraisers, estimate reviewers and umpires. We are not a law firm and we don’t act as public adjusters. We take one role per claim and we’ll tell you if appraisal isn’t a fit. If you’d like a free initial review, request one here, or read more about how we work.

Keep reading

Think the carrier’s number is too low?

Send the estimate and a handful of photos. We’ll tell you what we see, free.

Call now Free review